There are so many tasty ways to make rice pudding. These recipes span the gamut from stovetop and baked to crockpot and Instant Pot. There are recipes using cooked rice, raw rice, and even instant rice. Plus there are flavors too, from classic to chocolate and even banana. Check out this collection of delicious rice pudding recipes and get ready to make something cozy and delicious!
There is something so special and nostalgic about a warm, comforting bowl of rice pudding. It is one of those simple desserts that feels like a big hug, whether you are enjoying it warm right off the stove or chilled straight from the fridge.
Over the years, my love for rice pudding has led me to test all kinds of fun variations. Whether you have leftover cooked rice in the fridge, a pouch of instant rice, or raw long grain rice sitting in your pantry, there is a recipe here to match what you have on hand.
Email Me The Link
I'll email this post to you, so you can easily find it later. Plus you’ll get new recipes from me every week!
I have included quick pressure cooker methods for busy nights, slow cooker recipes for hands-off cooking, baked custards, and even dairy-free and fruit-sweetened options.
Gather your favorite mug or dessert bowl and explore these easy, delicious twists on a classic favorite!
Our Favorite Rice Pudding Recipes
Creamy Rice Pudding With Evaporated Milk
This creamy rice pudding recipe gives you that old-fashioned stovetop cozy flavor without taking hours to make. Using evaporated milk and raw rice, it makes rich pudding with a hint of cinnamon and nutmeg in about 25 minutes. It is my go-to when I want a quick, nostalgic dessert using simple pantry staples.
This baked rice pudding is fantastic when you have leftover cooked rice that you want to transform into something special. Sweetened condensed milk gives the custard a wonderful rich sweetness, and baking it creates that delicious golden layer on top that sets it apart from stovetop versions.
I love this slow cooker method because you simply measure, dump, and stir your ingredients in the crockpot. As it cooks, the condensed milk slightly caramelizes and gives the pudding an incredible depth of flavor with almost zero hand-on effort.
When you crave rice pudding right away but don't have pre-cooked rice ready, this Instant Pot recipe is a total lifesaver. Using uncooked long grain rice and the porridge setting, your pressure does all of the work to make a thick, rich pudding in a fraction of the time.
This rice pudding is perfect for anyone looking for a wholesome dessert option or a creative way to use overripe bananas. It turns leftover rice, a splash of milk, honey, and ripe banana into a creamy treat that satisfies your sweet tooth without refined sugar.
I developed this lower-and-slower oven method specifically for days when you don't have leftover rice cooked in advance. Raw long grain rice bakes directly in a generous amount of milk and egg custard, producing a thick, cozy baked pudding with slightly caramelized edges.
For chocolate lovers, this fun twist brings the cozy comfort of hot chocolate straight to your rice pudding bowl. Cooking uncooked rice with cocoa powder and milk in the Instant Pot, then stirring in sweetened condensed milk at the end, makes a rich and creamy chocolate dessert.
This recipe is idea for anyone who needs a naturally dairy-free dessert or just loves tropical flavors. Canned coconut milk creates a silky, luxurious texture as the rice cooks on the stovetop, and topping it with the toasted coconut makes it feel extra special.
This recipe gives you maximum creaminess without needing eggs or extra thickening agents. A quick 30-minute soak softens raw white rice so it cooks up perfectly tender in sweetened condensed milk and water.
If instant rice is what you keep stocked in your pantry, this slow cooker recipe is tailored just for you. Combining instant rice with whole milk, sugar, butter, and warm spices in the crockpot produces a classic, velvety dessert that feels like grandma made it.
This is the rice pudding recipe that started it all. It turns leftover rice, milk, eggs, and sugar into a fabulous dessert. The custard sets nicely and hits all of the right notes.
Carlee is a busy mom that loves to share family friendly recipes. There are a mix of quick and easy Midwest comfort food meals and plenty of sweet treats.
Whether you are looking for an old fashioned recipe from Carlee's grandma's recipe box or a new meal to feed your family, you are in the right place. There are plenty of delicious recipes for every cooking skill level and amount of time available.
